Argument over use of Northwest Passage continues

Argument over use of Northwest Passage continues


For centuries theorized as a possible trade route, the effects of global warming have allowed navigable routes through the Northwest Passage to be traversed again.

Stories about Argument over use of Northwest Passage continues

Changes with global warming

  • Provo, UT

Recently, there has been extensive debate about the debilitating effects of global warming, and how the melting of the ice caps is disrupting global ecological systems.  Such is the case in the area known as the Northwest Passage, a region above the Arctic Circle.  Since preliminary voyages in 1906 by Roald Admundsen, explorers have sought to establish a permanent route from the Atlantic Ocean to the Pacific Ocean.  This was difficult, however, because of the harsh climate of the region, leaving many areas around the Arctic Ocean frozen year round.  As a result of global warming, these once isolated passages are being reopened, thus allowing sailors to traverse through the Canadian islands to the Pacific Ocean.  The following is an article from The Washington Post, which explains this new development:


<div>Dispute Over NW Passage RevivedU.S. Asserts Free Use by All Ships; Canada Claims Jurisdiction
<div>By [Doug Struck](</div>

Washington Post Foreign Service
Monday, November 6, 2006; Page A18


TORONTO -- A long-standing legal wrangle between the United States and Canada could complicate future shipping through the Arctic as global warming melts the ice in the Northwest Passage.

The United States contends that the Northwest Passage, though owned by Canada, is an international strait with free passage for all, like other straits around the world. U.S. officials say they are following a long-standing position in favor of keeping straits free to all navigation and want unimpeded movement of U.S. ships.

Canada counters that it has sole jurisdiction over the Northwest Passage and wants to enforce its own laws on ships in the Arctic waters. Canadian officials argue that their authority over the myriad channels and straits that make up the legendary route from the Atlantic to the Pacific is the best way to minimize unsafe ships and accidental spills in the pristine North.

The issue has suddenly come alive because climate change is reducing the Arctic ice pack that prevents regular shipping through the passage.

In an unusual twist last week, the former U.S. ambassador to Canada, Paul Cellucci, was quoted in Canadian newspapers as saying that he agreed with the Canadian position. "It is in the security interests of the United States that it be under the control of Canada," he said at a conference in Ottawa.

Cellucci's comments prompted the current U.S. ambassador, David Wilkins, to restate U.S. insistence that the Northwest Passage is an international strait.

The spat has flared occasionally in the past. Canadians were incensed when Americans drove the reinforced oil tanker Manhattan through the Northwest Passage in 1969, followed by the icebreaker Polar Sea in 1985, both without asking for Canadian permission.

Usually, however, the two countries have ignored their differences, agreeing that icebreakers do not need permission to pass and refusing to acknowledge the regular traffic of undersea nuclear submarines that use the passage.

Michael Byers, an international law expert at the University of British Columbia, said that if foreign ships begin using the route, Canada will lose its claim of oversight.

Canada has no search-and-rescue helicopters regularly based in the north and has disbanded the one military unit capable of dropping onto the ice. The country has no submarine that can travel under the ice cap. Its icebreakers are old and considered mid-weight; they leave the Arctic for the winter. The government has promised to build three new, powerful icebreakers and a deep-water port at Iqaluit, the capital of the Canadian territory of Nunavut, but has failed to fund any of those projects.

"If a foreign vessel wanted to come through here right now, it could," Byers said. "It's a big welcome mat for all the fly-by-night companies.""

It is interesting to note how this affects many North American communities.  The idea of increased trade is of significant importance to national agencies.

See all 1 stories…

Additional Info
kwright -Contributions private
View count:
120 (recently viewed: 1)